It was a crisp autumn afternoon, the kind where the air smelled of woodsmoke and damp earth, that my father sat me down at the kitchen table. I must have been eight, maybe nine. I’d taken a toy from a friend’s house, a small, intricate metal puzzle. Nothing major, just a careless moment of wanting. My friend had found it missing, and my parents had found it in my backpack.
My father, a man whose presence filled a room with a quiet strength, didn’t yell. He rarely did. Instead, he just looked at me with those steady, knowing eyes. “Son,” he began, his voice low and calm, “the world might forgive many things. Mistakes, accidents, even anger. But a lie… a lie eats at the soul. It eats at the trust between people, and once that trust is gone, it’s almost impossible to get back.”
He picked up a clean plate from the drying rack. “Imagine this plate is your reputation, your word. Spotless, right?” He smiled gently. Then, he let it slip from his fingers. It shattered on the linoleum with a deafening CRASH.
People at an airport | Source: Pexels
My breath hitched. I stared at the jagged pieces.
“See?” he said, kneeling beside me, picking up a shard carefully. “Even if we try to glue it back together, it’ll never be quite the same. There will always be cracks. Always signs it was broken.” He looked at me, his gaze unwavering. “Honesty is the glue that holds everything together. Without it, everything falls apart.”
That lesson, that broken plate, etched itself into my very being. It became my compass. My guiding star. I grew up believing in absolute truth, in transparency, in facing consequences no matter how difficult. It wasn’t always easy, but it felt right. I chose friends who valued sincerity. I pursued a career where integrity was paramount. I believed, with every fibre of my being, that living an honest life was the only path to genuine peace.
My father was my hero. He embodied everything he preached. A man of his word. Unyielding in his principles. He was the rock of our family, the silent protector, the one who always knew the right thing to say, the right thing to do. My mother adored him. I worshipped him.
A man sitting on a bench | Source: Pexels
Years passed. Life threw its usual curveballs. There were times when lying seemed like the easier option, the path of least resistance. A small white lie to avoid hurting someone’s feelings. A convenient omission to prevent an argument. But every time, the image of that broken plate, my father’s earnest face, would flash in my mind. And every time, I chose the truth.
One particular instance stands out. My partner, years into our relationship, confided in me about a financial mistake they’d made, a secret they’d kept from their family for months, fearing their disappointment. It wasn’t my secret to tell, but it was eating at them. They asked for my advice, my support in keeping it hidden just a little longer.
My heart ached for them. I saw their fear, their shame. The easy thing, the loving thing, would have been to agree. To help them maintain the facade. But I couldn’t. I physically couldn’t. My father’s voice echoed in my head, “a lie eats at the soul.”
A sleeping baby | Source: Pexels
I sat them down, much like my father had sat me down all those years ago. “You have to tell them,” I said, my voice gentle but firm. “It will be hard. It might hurt. But it’s the only way to heal it. The longer you wait, the bigger the crack becomes.” It was a tough conversation. There were tears, anger, resentment even. But eventually, they faced the truth, confessed, and began the painful process of repair.
My father, when I told him about the situation (omitting details, of course, to respect my partner’s privacy), had simply nodded. “Good man,” he’d said, a rare, genuine smile gracing his lips. “It takes courage to choose honesty when it’s hard. That’s true strength.” That moment, his approval, felt like the highest honour. It validated everything I believed in.
Then came the spring cleaning. My mother had finally convinced my father to clear out the attic, a forgotten space filled with decades of accumulated memories. Boxes upon boxes, dusty and overflowing. My father, never one for sentimentality, simply wanted it done. My mother, on the other hand, treated each item like an archaeological find, recounting stories with every dust-laden trinket. I was there, helping, mostly enjoying the trip down memory lane.
An open laptop | Source: Pexels
We stumbled upon an old cedar chest, tucked away in a dark corner, beneath a pile of faded tarps. It wasn’t locked. It felt heavy, filled with an odd assortment of things. Old photo albums, brittle with age. My mother gasped, delight clearly evident. “Oh, these must be your father’s things from before we met!”
My father, who was usually indifferent to these discoveries, suddenly seemed… tense. His movements became stiff. “Just old junk,” he mumbled, trying to wave us away. That’s odd, I thought. He’s usually so calm.
My mother ignored him, already pulling out a thick, leather-bound album. The first few pages were familiar – pictures of a young, dashing version of my father, serving in the army, on adventurous trips with friends. But then, deeper in the album, the pictures changed.
There was a woman. Beautiful, with kind eyes and a warm smile. She was often by my father’s side. In some photos, they were holding hands. In others, they were embracing. A past girlfriend, maybe? I thought, not really processing it. My father had been a handsome man; it wasn’t surprising.
A shocked woman staring at her laptop | Source: Pexels
Then my mother turned a page, and a small, loose photograph fluttered out, landing face-down on the dusty floor. I picked it up.
It was a picture of my father, younger, undeniably him, holding a baby. A tiny, bundled infant, no more than a few months old, nestled against his chest. His smile in the photo was wide, genuine, filled with a tenderness I’d only ever seen directed at me or my mother. And beside him, her arm around his waist, was the same beautiful woman from the other photos. She was beaming.
My mother made a small, choked sound. “What… what is this?” Her voice was barely a whisper.
My father, who had been standing rigid, suddenly slumped against a dusty trunk. His face was ashen. His eyes, usually so steady, darted away, unable to meet ours.
I looked at the baby. And then, my gaze slid to the back of the photo, where a faded inscription, scrawled in handwriting that was unmistakably my father’s, read: “Our little angel. November 12th, 1968.”
An excited woman looking at her laptop | Source: Pexels
My birthday was October 20th, 1975. This child was years older than me.
A cold dread seeped into my bones. No. It can’t be. My mind raced, trying to find a logical explanation. A niece? A nephew? But the way they looked at each other, the way my father held the baby… that wasn’t an uncle’s pride.
My eyes snapped to my father. He wouldn’t look at me. He wouldn’t look at my mother, who now held the photo with trembling hands, her face a mask of disbelief and betrayal.
“Dad?” my voice came out strangled, barely audible. “Who… who is this?”
He finally met my gaze. His eyes were filled with unshed tears, regret, and a profound, bone-deep weariness. He opened his mouth, but no words came out. His shoulders shook.
A woman frowning on the sofa | Source: Pexels
And then, I turned the page of the album my mother still held. There, tucked inside a folded letter, was a faded, official-looking document. A birth certificate. It listed the woman’s name as the mother. And my father’s full name as the father. The child’s name was clearly printed. A name I had never heard before. A name that now seemed to scream at me in the silent attic.
MY FATHER HAD ANOTHER FAMILY. A CHILD HE NEVER TOLD US ABOUT.
My entire world, everything I believed in, every lesson he’d ever taught me, every word he’d ever spoken about honesty, about the glue that holds everything together, shattered around me like that ceramic plate on the kitchen floor. Only this time, the pieces weren’t just jagged; they were razor-sharp, tearing through the very fabric of my soul.
A woman suspecting | Source: Pexels
ALL THOSE YEARS. ALL THOSE SERMONS. ALL THAT TALK OF TRUTH.
It was all a lie. My hero. The man who taught me that a lie eats at the soul. He had been living one for decades. And the worst part? I was standing in the shattered pieces of his hypocrisy, because of the very honesty he had so carefully, so diligently, taught me to cherish.
